Five Solas of the Reformation (Part 4): Solus Christus, “Christ alone”

[An audio recording of the sermon will be uploaded here after Sunday service]

I saw a disturbing video on Instagram. In the video, a Protestant pastor took several statues of the Virgin Mary and smashed them in front of his congregation. When I watched that, I remembered talking with a Protestant friend who proudly said, “I confronted my Catholic co-worker and told him straight up, ‘You Catholics pray to Mary and the saints. That goes against what the Bible teaches!’”

I felt that the video and my friend did not demonstrate the gentleness and respect that Christians are called to.

Something that could help Protestants be more gracious is to understand what the Catholic Church teaches. Many Protestants were taught Catholicism is bad, but often we do not really know what Catholics believe and why.

I brought up those stories about Catholic devotion to the Virgin Mary because it’s related to the topic of today’s sermon. I’m continuing a series of sermons about the five solas—which were five core teachings of the Protestant Reformation.

Today’s sola is called solus Christus, which means “Christ alone.” Solus Christus can be summarized like this: Jesus Christ is the only one who can mediate between God and man for our salvation. No other person, saint, priest, church, or religious system can save us.

To understand solus Christus more, it helps to understand what the Church during Martin Luther’s time taught about Mary, the saints, and something called the treasury of merit. I will summarize what the medieval Catholics believed and how Luther and other Reformers responded. Then I’ll share two reflections. The first reflection is about how Protestants can have a healthy interest in the saints. The second is about sharing the gospel of “Christ alone” with non-Christians. Before we begin, let us pray.

Mary and the saints

Let’s start by understanding how the Catholic Church developed its beliefs about Mary and the saints.

The early Church had a calendar that helped believers reflect on the life and work of Jesus throughout the year. At different points of the year, believers commemorated Jesus’ birth, baptism, ministry, suffering and death, resurrection, and ascension.

In addition, early Christians also developed a custom of remembering believers died for their faith. This became part of the Church calendar. Early Christians commemorated these martyrs by gathering near their graves, remembering them as examples of faithfulness, and affirming the hope that God would one day raise them from the dead and vindicate them.

Over time, this custom of remembering martyrs evolved in a new direction. More and more Christians believed that these holy men and women in heaven could pray to God on behalf of the living. Some Christians found support for this in Revelation 5:8 and 8:3, which mention heavenly figures presenting the prayers of people to God. Is this a correct interpretation? That remains a debate today.

Anyway, devotion to these saints in heaven grew. Certain saints became associated with certain needs. People prayed to one saint for healing, and to another saint for safety while traveling.

Even Martin Luther himself, having grown up in this environment, was once caught in terrible thunderstorm and cried out to St Anne, the mother of Mary. He was so afraid he would die he vowed to St Anne that he would become a monk if he survived.

The medieval Church calendar added more feast days to commemorate saints, making their stories an increasingly important part of Christian life. Mary was particularly important among the saints. Some Christians found it easier to approach Mary or other saints rather than Jesus himself. They had an impression of Jesus as a stern judge, while Mary and the saints seemed more compassionate and approachable. That’s why they asked the saints to pray to God on their behalf.

By the late Middle Ages, devotion to Mary had developed considerably. She had titles such as the Mediatrix (which means mediator), Queen of Heaven, and Advocate.

Treasury of merit

At the same time, another teaching developed within the Church, called the treasury of merit. To understand merit, let’s recall the medieval Catholic view of sin and punishment.

Medieval Catholics believed in two kinds of punishment for sin: eternal and temporal.

Eternal punishment includes loss of relationship with God and afterlife in hell. This can be avoided through steps like trusting in Christ’s salvation and cooperating with God’s grace. But even after receiving God’s forgiveness, there can be temporal punishment. Temporal punishment is consequences of sin that have not been healed.

Think of it this way: If you break your neighbor’s window, he might forgive you; but the window remains broken until it is fixed. Likewise, Catholics believed they needed to be purified from temporal punishment—either while alive, or while in Purgatory (which is after death and before heaven). To be purified from temporal punishment there were many steps a believer could take, such as repentance, prayer, and charity. Another option was to receive indulgences from the Church.

Indulgences can remove temporal punishment by drawing from a treasury of merit in heaven. This merit has been accumulated by Jesus Christ, Mary, and the saints. The merit of saints comes from their good actions that flowed out of union with Christ and cooperating with God’s grace. So, the medieval Church believed it could draw merit from this treasury to remove temporal punishment.

By the late Middle Ages, indulgences were a significant feature of the Church in Western Europe. Believers could obtain indulgences through religious acts, but increasingly through donations and other financial transactions.

So, that was the world of medieval Church, the environment in which Luther lived before the Reformation began.

Reformers’ response to devotion to the saints

Now, let me summarize Luther and the other Reformers’ critique of these beliefs.

The Reformers were concerned that devotion to Mary and the saints undermined the unique role of Jesus as the one who brings us to God.

In 1 Timothy 2:5, Paul writes, “For there is one God, and there is one mediator between God and men, the man Christ Jesus.” In other words, we do not need another heavenly helper to talk to God.

And if we are afraid of coming to Jesus or the Father, then perhaps we have the wrong image of him. Hebrews 4:15-16 says, “For we do not have a high priest who is unable to empathize with our weaknesses, but we have one who has been tempted in every way, just as we are—yet he did not sin. Let us then approach God’s throne of grace with confidence, so that we may receive mercy and find grace to help us in our time of need.”

Catholics might respond to this by saying that they are not treating Mary and the saints as equal to Jesus. Rather, asking saints in heaven to pray for us is similar to asking another believer on earth to pray for us.

Now, the Reformers understood the Catholic view, but they questioned whether Scripture really supported the practice of asking the saints in heaven to intercede for us. They were concerned that devotion to saints might lead people to depend on the saints instead of on Jesus.

However, the Reformers did agree on with the medieval Church that we can honour faithful believers who have gone to heaven and learn from their example.

Reformers’ response to treasury of merit

But as for the teaching about merit and indulgences, the Reformers opposed that.

They thought that buying indulgences to gain merit could give people a false sense of repentance. This was one of Luther’s main concerns during his famous protest against in 1517. Luther said the Church needed to recover biblical teaching that forgiveness and salvation are gifts of God, received through faith in Jesus Christ—not something that can be bought by us.

What Jesus did for us is complete and sufficient. When Jesus hung on the Cross, he declared: “It is finished” (John 19:30). Jesus paid for our sins completely. We don’t need to borrow further merit from the saints.

Hebrews 10:14 adds, “For by one sacrifice he has made perfect forever those who are being made holy.” Of course we must still repent and grow in obedience to God. But we repent and obey as a response to God’s gift of forgiveness—not to buy forgiveness.

Solus Christus

For the Reformers, then, the phrase solus Christus or “Christ alone” was an important call to put Jesus back at the centre of faith and church practices.

Christ alone is our Savior. Christ alone can be the mediator and reconciler between God and man. No other person or religious system can add to His finished work on the Cross.

As Jesus said in John 14:6, “I am the way, and the truth, and the life. No one comes to the Father except through me.”

Healthy interest in the saints

Having said that, that doesn’t mean Protestants should reject Catholics’ interest in the saints. I would argue that Protestants can benefit from learning about the saints and even commemorate them—as long as it doesn’t draw us away focusing on Jesus.

For example, I found that reading the writings of early Church fathers has enriched my faith. Such as St Anthony, an Egyptian monk who is often called the father of Christian monastics. Anthony took Jesus’ words very seriously about selling his possessions to follow the Lord. Reading his story made me wonder if I take Jesus’s teachings seriously.

I think it’s great if we can learn from the lives of the saints, praise God for what He did through them, and see we are part of a large family of believers that God has sustained over hundreds of years. Our interest in the saints is healthy when their example encourages us to love Jesus more deeply.

The question is: who is the focus, ultimately? There’s a big annual celebration on the island of Penang, which is in the north part of Malaysia. The celebration commemorates St Anne, mother of Mary. It’s similar to a matsuri in Japan where people carry omikoshi. In the feast of St Anne, there’s a procession where devotees carry St Anne’s statue and bring their prayer requests to her. I watched a TV interview with a Hindu woman who joined the procession. She said, “I hope St Anne will grant my prayers.” I wonder if she came away knowing more about Jesus, or if her attention was only on St Anne.

This is what the Reformers were concerned about. If devotion to the saints surpasses devotion to Christ, we may lose sight of the gospel.

But this is not just a Catholic problem. Protestants also allow parts of religious life to overshadow their relationship with Jesus.

For example, some Protestant services are more like entertainment rather than worship. To give an extreme example, I saw a video of one Christmas service in a megachurch that was the most spectacular I’ve ever seen. Christmas is often a big celebration with bright decorations and special performances, but this megachurch also had acrobats and live animals—even live camels! I wondered if this really helped people be interested in Jesus, or was it just a circus?

So, whether we are Catholic or Protestant, we have the same danger of making other things our focus rather than God.

Also, I think Protestants tend to over-react against Catholicism. We are so wary of Catholic reverence for the saints that we disconnect from the history we share with Catholics. There’s a large gap in our knowledge of Christianity between the years of the early Church and the Reformation 1500 years later. But in fact, there were faithful Christians throughout the centuries that we can learn from, and many of them were part of what we call the Catholic Church. As for Catholic traditions, even Martin Luther thought that many traditions should be retained—if they are beneficial and do not contradict Scripture.

Sharing solus Christus with non-Christians

Up until now, we have been talking about the Catholic view versus the Protestant view. I want to end by looking beyond our denominational differences. Ultimately, we don’t want to get stuck debating each other and forget that God called us to share about our Savior with the rest of the world.

Solus Christus, Christ alone, is not an easy message to share. Saying that we need Jesus and only Jesus to save us is an offensive message to many non-Christians.

One of our mamatomo from Sophie’s kindergarten asked, “Can I become a Christian and still keep my current religion? I ask because my religion allows me to be part of other religions as well.”

It’s not easy to give a truthful yet gentle answer. We really need to pray for courage and wisdom for ourselves, and pray for the Spirit’s work in the other person’s heart. Last month I talked about sola gratia, “grace alone.” Only God, by his grace, can draw people to his Son Jesus.

In summary, I told our friend that Christians worship Jesus alone; so in practice, we should not have another religion if we are Christians. She didn’t seem offended by my answer, and we continue to have a good relationship. Even if she was offended, our friendship mattered much more than our difference in beliefs.

I hope you will take heart from this. Though sharing the truth can cause a very negative response, sometimes the response can be neutral or even positive.

The idea of solus Christus, Christ alone, may be offensive to one person but refreshing to another person. Some people are relieved to hear the good news that our future depends on Jesus, not on our actions. It’s wonderful that we don’t have to strive to be accepted by God, by people, or by ourselves.

So, as we try to share the good news of Jesus, there are a few things we can do. Prayer is one. Building the friendship is another. And one more thing is to be clear about the beauty of the gospel. The gospel is not just made of hard truths like “you are a sinner”. The gospel is also made of wonderful, comforting, life-giving truths like “you do not have to keep striving”’; or “there is Someone looking out for you” and “He is powerful and good”; “He invites you to talk with him.”

Conclusion

To conclude, Jesus Christ alone is our hope. He welcomes us with arms open. Through Jesus, we can come confidently to God the Father. Even though he knows our every weakness and mistake, he is not waiting to criticise but to embrace us. May our brothers and sisters from past centuries encourage us to love him and be loved by him.

Let’s pray. Hasten, O Father, the coming of your kingdom; and grant that we your servants, who now live by faith, may with joy behold your Son at his coming in glorious majesty; even Jesus Christ, our only Mediator and Advocate. Amen.

 

Copied title and URL